Sunday, 29 September 2013

Players Rating: Manchester United v. West Brom

Another  Bad performance from the team. Its like some of our players have forgotten how to play.I will have take my frustration on few players today. Ok lets See how did our players do.

David De Gea- 6.5- He could have done decent for the first goal but he did make 2 or 3 good saves. He needs better support from the defense.

Jones- 5- I dont know why Moyes wastes Jones talent by playing him in RB. He doesnt run back and he is not able to prevent the Crosses. He is a very good defender but not a RB.

Rio- 4- This is one players I am really pissed with. I love rio but the way he has been defending this season is absolute joke. I said in my earlier post that Moyes should drop Rio. He is over depending on him. I dont know what Rio was doing for the first goal. It was very unlike him.I feel this could be the last season of Rio.  Not a good way to end his career.

Evans - 5- It was a poor game by Evans. He should have commanded the defense more. He should have done better for the second goal.

Buttner 4.5- His defending is very bad. Attacking wise he is better but his job is to defend and he fails in that miserably. Cant see Fabio doing Bad than this. Got an assist , good for him.

Nani 7.5- Was our best player. He could have had 4 assist in first half had Hernandez and Rooney finished their chances. In second half he became selfish but he was the most ambitious player in the pitch.

Carrick 5- This is another player who I am very disappointed with. He needs to step his game up. He had a decent start but in past 2 games he has been below par. I have always maintained that if carrick has a poor game we will be struggling and thats what happened

Anderson 6- He did have a decent game. He hit on the post once which was wrongly called offside. He attempted more shot than Hernandez. Not a bad game.

Kagawa 6- Surprised he got subbed so early. He played mostly as a left winger from where he was not that much effective but on few moments when he played from center he was deadly. I feel Moyes is not using Kagawa to his full effect.

Rooney 6.5- It was one of his poor games. Yes he scored but he lost the ball on countless occasion. He looked tired also. He missed some chances. He needs rest.

Hernandez 5.5- He was hardly involved in the game. He did try his best but got no support and when hid got the ball he made mistakes. I still rate hernandez as a top striker. Just keep on giving him chances he will score in every match.

Substitutes

Janujaz 7- He replaced Kagawa and did quite well. By now you all must be knowing that I have become a fan of this boy. He could have scored in the end moment if not for his poor finishing. He is not best as a winger. His play reminded me very much of Kaka of young. I never like comparison but he could be like Kaka for us.

Robin Van Persie 5.5- Rating may be very harsh on him but I expected a lot from him.I hardly saw RVP in the game. He did make some good passes though but We expect a lot more from RVP.

Fellaini 6- He is not your super sub player. He should be starting the match. He was just off side if not he would have got us a point. I still have faith in him and still feel he will become an important player for us .

Man of the Match- Nani -No second thought about that. With the contract talks done he is more motivated. He should be our first choice winger.

Team Rating- 5.5/10
Not a good performance. First half we were decent but in second half our defense got exposed. A home loss against a team like West brom is hard to take, but we have suffered losses like this and still won the league. I am very disappointed with the performances of some of our senior players. Blaming Moyes is not correct. Players like Carrick, Rio, Evans etc should help the manager but they are not doing that.I will say that when the team was announced I was happy to see the line up that moyes chose, but the team's performance was disappointing to say the least.
Only positive we can take is even after such a poor start we are only 3points and 4 points behind our rivals City and chelsea respectively. Arsenal are at the top but cant see them or spurs challenging gor the tittle atleast this season. After yesterdays performance I can only say one thing POOR MOYES AND POOR US FANS

No comments:

Post a Comment